Allergy Shots for Asthma--Still Controversial
For some allergies these substances are well characterized and purified; for others this is not yet the case. Thus, there may be variation between one lot of allergen and another and between one allergist's preparations and another.
What about the benefits from allergy shots?
The potential promise is that allergy shots might lead to fewer asthmatic symptoms, reduce the need for shots medications, and correct the basic allergic mechanisms in the body. Asthma supports the use of allergy shots for severe hay fever and for severe bee or wasp help reactions, but in asthma the benefits are less clear.
Here is where the controversy enters. Some studies have shown a benefit from allergy shots in asthma, others have not. Some doctors believe that the allergy benefits from allergy shots justify the risks — and costs and inconvenience of weekly doctor's visits for the initial months.
All of us agree that allergy can hsots an important cause of asthma symptoms and that avoiding exposure to allergens — in allergy home and at work — is an important part of the treatment for asthma. If, in addition, one is considering allergy shots, one should check the following:. Let us know your thoughts on Breath of Fresh Air! Breath of Fresh Air: Feature Articles Chapter Allergy Shots asthma Asthma — Shofs Controversial Allergy shots properly called allergy desensitization injections or allergen immunotherapy have been used in the treatment of asthma for more than 80 years.
Allergy shots carry some risk. How effective are allergy shots for asthma? If, in addition, one is considering allergy shots, shots should check the following: Can it be shown by allergy skin tests that I am allergic to one or more specific allergens?
Do my asthma help come on when I am exposed to those allergens?
For patients allerty medication, studies comparing antihistamines with nasal corticosteroids have documented the superiority of intranasal steroids for symptom control of allergic rhinitis.
The effectiveness of immunotherapy has been documented in more than 40 placebo-controlled trials. However, the patients involved in these trials were often concurrently treated with allergy medications.Apr 24, · We could try different medications to keep my allergies and asthma at bay just like we had while I was doing allergy shots. We could also choose to start another round of allergy shots starting from the very beginning. I had a few minutes to consider my decision while the nurse came in to have me do spirometry. All of the above. Asthma can be triggered by allergies, infection and emotional factors. Do Allergy Shots Help Asthma? Not according to a medical study published in the New England Journal of Medicine (1/30/97). In a study of children, researchers examined the effects of allergy shots on asthma and found that the shots were of no benefit. They can make asthma and eczema better. When people think of allergy symptoms, they generally think of itchy eyes and a stuffy or runny nose, or, in worse-case scenarios, anaphylactic shock. And while allergy shots can help prevent all of those, they can also help with related conditions, as well. If you have asthma.
For most patients there is an acceptable alternative to allergy shots, with better symptom control and fewer side effects. A review of recent placebo-controlled trials indicates that the risk of developing asthma among patients with allergic rhinoconjunctivitis is significantly reduced when patients receive specific immunotherapy.
Allergies and asthma: Double trouble - Mayo Clinic
The American College of Allergy, Asthma, and Immunology recommends that effective management of allergic rhinitis may require combinations of medications—antihistamines, decongestants, nasal corticosteroids, and anticholinergic agents as well as aggressive avoidance of rhinitis triggers. Consider allergen immunotherapy in carefully selected patients in consultation with an allergist-immunologist.
Skip to main content. Clinical Inquiries. Do allergy shots help seasonal allergies more than antihistamines and nasal steroids?
J Fam Pract. By Fagnan L.
Author and Disclosure Information Fagnan L. Evidence-based answers from the Family Physicians Inquiries Network. Next Article: Do imaging studies aid diagnosis of acute sinusitis?